Where To Buy Silver In Setauket-East Setauket, New York

Buying Silver Near Setauket-East Setauket Is Easy As 1...2...3!

Step 1
Place Your Order Online!

Step 2
Silver shipped in 24 hours!

Step 3
Your Silver arives!

Buying silver in Setauket-East Setauket, New York has never been easier! Dozens of local and national silver dealers are standing by to help you invest!

Local Silver Dealers

1) A & D Gold And Silver Coins

4.49 Miles Away (631) 584-7070 428 Lake Ave Saint James, NY 11780

2) Center Island Gold

5.01 Miles Away (631) 600-7656 2570 Middle Country Rd Brookhaven, NY 11720

3) Center Gold

5.05 Miles Away (631) 467-0400 2340 Middle Country Rd Centereach, NY 11720

4) Gem Pawnbrokers

5.84 Miles Away (631) 946-6666 430 Middle Country Road Selden, NY 11784

5) All Good Gold Exchange

7.52 Miles Away (631) 767-9270 343C Hawkins Ave Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

6) R & S Diamond Exchange

8.20 Miles Away (631) 821-0689 285 Rte 25A Rocky Point, NY 11778

7) William J O'Neill Sales Exchange

12.25 Miles Away (631) 289-9899 1 E Main St Patchogue, NY 11772

8) Budget Buy and Sell

12.29 Miles Away (631) 758-6363 2 E Main St Patchogue, NY 11772

9) Miller's Mint

12.42 Miles Away (631) 475-5353 313 E Main St Patchogue, NY 11772

10) Premier Coin Galleries

13.29 Miles Away (800) 820-5006 3240 Sunrise Hwy Ste 100 East Islip, NY 11730

Silver Purchase Formats

There are a number of physical formats you can consider when buying silver:


  • Silver Coins: Some coins have a "rarity" component associated with them that can add to their value. Coins are a great option but avoid purchasing based on rarity unless you really know what you're doing
  • Silver Jewelry: Investing in jewelry is another option. You'll take craftsmansip, design, and purity into account when valuing these items.
  • Silver Bars: Bars are typically quite pure, and stamped with the name of the production refinery. Value is directly aligned to the amount of metal in the bar.
  • Silver ETFs: These are funds designed to follow the spot price of silver. It doesn't mean you own anything physically, and isn't an effective hedge against total system collapse (but can be a good investment vehicle for some).

Tips For Buying Silver In New York

Stick To Physical Silver Coins, Bullion, and Jewelry

Silver owned through a commodities exchange, or "on paper" is no substitute for physical bars, coins, or jewelry. Exchanges are heavily leveraged, which means if everyone tried to "cash out" at once, there isn't enough physical metal to go around.


Moreover, precious metals are typically meant as a hedge against the complete collapse of the traditional banking infrastructure. If you wind up needing it, you'll want to have it close at hand!

Keep Some Silver Nearby - But Not Too Much

Governments around the world have seized noble metals from time to time, so keeping your entire stash locally could be a bad idea depending on where you live.


Safe jurisdictions like Switzerland should be considered when you get to the point of holding a significant (tens of thousands of dollars worth generally) amount.

Invest On A Long Time Horizon

When investing in any asset, including silver, it's important to keep the time horizon in mind. Prices fluctuate, and over a longer time horizon there's a better chance of your investment appreciating in value.


The last thing anyone would want is to invest money they'll need in the coming months, only to have the market move against them. Talk to your financial adviser, and carefully plan any future purchases.

Stay Liquid

Having liquid silver on-hand and ready in the event of a crisis is the best hedge. Being invested in silver ETFs is fine depending on your objectives, but if you're truly hedging against unforeseen market collapses, you want physical metal in your possession.