Where To Sell Silver In Setauket-East Setauket, New York

Selling Silver Near Setauket-East Setauket Is Easy As 1...2...3!

Step 1
Request an appraisal kit!

Step 2
Ship your silver!

Step 3
Get paid cash!

Selling silver in Setauket-East Setauket, New York shouldn't be a hassle! Tons of local and national silver dealers are paying top dollar for your unwanted metals!

Local Silver Dealers

1) A & D Gold And Silver Coins

4.49 Miles Away (631) 584-7070 428 Lake Ave Saint James, NY 11780

2) Center Island Gold

5.01 Miles Away (631) 600-7656 2570 Middle Country Rd Brookhaven, NY 11720

3) Center Gold

5.05 Miles Away (631) 467-0400 2340 Middle Country Rd Centereach, NY 11720

4) Gem Pawnbrokers

5.84 Miles Away (631) 946-6666 430 Middle Country Road Selden, NY 11784

5) All Good Gold Exchange

7.52 Miles Away (631) 767-9270 343C Hawkins Ave Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

6) R & S Diamond Exchange

8.20 Miles Away (631) 821-0689 285 Rte 25A Rocky Point, NY 11778

7) William J O'Neill Sales Exchange

12.25 Miles Away (631) 289-9899 1 E Main St Patchogue, NY 11772

8) Budget Buy and Sell

12.29 Miles Away (631) 758-6363 2 E Main St Patchogue, NY 11772

9) Miller's Mint

12.42 Miles Away (631) 475-5353 313 E Main St Patchogue, NY 11772

10) Premier Coin Galleries

13.29 Miles Away (800) 820-5006 3240 Sunrise Hwy Ste 100 East Islip, NY 11730

Finding A Great Place To Sell Silver In Setauket-East Setauket

Whether you're selling silver coins, jewelry, or bars, it's critical to find a good buyer. There are a ton of businesses that trade in silver, and they're definitely not all created equally.


Frequently the value of a silver item is at least partially subjective, with things like rarity, craftsmanship, and other factors heavily influencing the value. It's important to go into any potential selling situation well informed to help you get the best price!


Whether you decide to go with a national service where your items are mailed in and appraised, or a dealer local to Setauket-East Setauket, research is key. Know who you're dealing with by checking with organizaions like the BBB, and know the value of your items by checking spot prices and getting competing offers.


Selling silver can be intimidating at first for a new-comer, but it doesn't have to be! As with all things in life, preperation is the key to success.


Tips For Selling Silver In New York

Stay Liquid

Having liquid silver on-hand and ready in the event of a crisis is the best hedge. Being invested in silver ETFs is fine depending on your objectives, but if you're truly hedging against unforeseen market collapses, you want physical metal in your possession.

Silver Purchase Format

As a general rule, you should look at buying legal tender silver coins wherever possible. This will almost certainly include less overhead and premium than other formats, and be closer to the true spot price of silver.


Purchasing rare silver coins should be avoided unless you really know what you're doing. Some subjective measures of value are easy to misjudge, and may result in you getting taken advantage of.

Maintain Direct Control Of Your Silver

If you're not buying an huge amount of silver, you should aim to maintain direct control over it at your home or other property.


If you're investing heavily, to the point where you need a safe alternative location to store it, be sure to go somewhere like Switzerland with strong property rights. It's key to make sure they can't lend or hedge using your stash.

Know And Comply With The Law

It's important to comply with the law when it comes to buying silver, and knowing what they are goes a long way.


Under a certain dollar amount, there's no need to declare (which may be attractive to some), but once you hit a threshold you will need to (and should) declare your holdings.